Welcome to our site. My apologizes for taking this long to answer to your forum post. I had been on vacation and internet was not always available.
Regarding the membership... well, they both offer the same benefits:
- One year subscription
- Tons of great products
- Each have their own Layout Gallery
- Email notification of new products
- They are both great deals in both quality and quantative.
The only difference between them is:
- The products themselves
- Two different designers. SgD DESIGNS (me) created the SgD Club Products. Donna Phillips (Pixel Princess) creates the Donna Club Products
They are both great clubs. Many members join both clubs at the same time, since joining both clubs give you download access to a large amount of digital scrapbooking products.
I hope this helps you make your decision.